Leading up to my online CEU course on Jing and nurturing life practices (
2 hours of CEUs for FREE, sign up here
), I sat down with scholar and Chinese medicine practitioner Dr. Phil Garrison to discuss Jing (Essence) and the less discussed Jing Shen.
PCOM-NY faculty member Jeremy Pulsifer was featured cooking a healing soup to treat a cough on PCOM alumna Jill Blakeway’s show “Grow Cook Heal”. Check it out!
And at #7: the Power of Placebo, featuring Ted Kaptchuk–Pacific Symposium 2013’s keynote speaker and a longtime PCOM associate!
“ 32 - Because joining a ragtag band of fellow travellers, cooks and guides as I trekked back from La Ciudad Perdida in Colombia reminded me of the joy of sharing your journey with others.”
In 404 CE, the first foreign medicine was imported into Japan from Korea, which has been deduced as being mostly herbal in nature.
During this time, waves of migration from the Korean peninsula brought Chinese technology and writings to the island nation. It was through these transplants that the native Japanese learned of Chinese medicine and acupuncture. As passageways between China and Japan became more open, the first formal introduction of acupuncture in Japan occurred in 562 by a Chinese monk name Zhi Cong. He made the trek across the Sea of China east and brought with him medical treatises on herbal medicine and acupuncture meridians including the Mingtang tu, also known as the Illustrated Manual of Channels, Collaterals, and Acupuncture Points.
Thanks to the Tunnel to Towers Foundation for honoring Pacific College for our support for the important work they do. And thanks to Dr. Jeff Poplarski who makes it all possible.
David Rich Sol, Dean of Asian Holistic Health and Massage of PCOM’s Chicago campus, talks extensively about this method to reduce pain and tension.
Acupuncture for Knee Osteoarthritis: Evidence and Treatment Approaches
Knee osteoarthritis is a common cause of pain, stiffness and reduced mobility in Australia. It can make stairs, squatting, gardening, walking the dog or getting up from a low chair increasingly difficult. Although it is often described as “wear and tear”, osteoarthritis involves changes in cartilage, bone, synovial tissue, muscles and pain processing, so symptoms do not always match an X-ray.
Acupuncture is one option within a broader osteoarthritis management plan. In traditional Chinese medicine, treatment may focus on the movement of qi and blood, local tenderness, meridian patterns and the person’s general constitution. In contemporary clinical settings, practitioners may describe the same treatment in terms of sensory nerve stimulation, muscle relaxation, altered pain signalling and improved function.
Research on acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis suggests that some people experience modest improvements in pain and physical ability, particularly over a course of treatment. The results are mixed, however, and acupuncture should not be presented as a way to rebuild worn cartilage or replace exercise, weight management, medication review or surgery when those treatments are indicated.
For Australians considering care, practical matters include finding a registered practitioner, understanding Medicare and private health insurance arrangements, and choosing a plan that fits local life. A person living in suburban Melbourne may need appointments around work and tram travel, while someone in regional Queensland may face longer journeys and fewer providers. These realities can affect whether a treatment course is sustainable.
Understanding Knee Osteoarthritis And Its Symptoms
Knee osteoarthritis commonly produces pain with walking, standing, stairs or prolonged sitting. Some people notice morning stiffness that eases within half an hour, while others experience swelling, grinding, reduced bending or a sense that the knee is unreliable. Pain may fluctuate with activity, sleep, stress, weather and the strength of the surrounding muscles.
Diagnosis is usually based on the medical history and a physical examination. X-rays can show joint-space narrowing, osteophytes and changes in bone, but imaging findings do not always explain the severity of pain. A person with striking radiographic changes may remain active with little discomfort, while another may have substantial symptoms with modest imaging changes.
A GP, physiotherapist or musculoskeletal specialist can assess other causes of knee pain, including meniscal injury, bursitis, inflammatory arthritis, referred pain and ligament problems. Sudden swelling, fever, redness, inability to bear weight or a locked knee warrants prompt medical assessment rather than routine acupuncture.
Traditional Chinese medicine assessment may include questions about pain quality, temperature, sleep, digestion and energy, as well as palpation of the knee and pulse. Treatment can therefore vary between people with similar biomedical diagnoses. The needles may be placed around the knee, in the lower leg or at distal points, depending on the practitioner’s approach.
What The Evidence Says About Acupuncture
Clinical trials generally compare acupuncture with usual care, sham acupuncture, education or exercise. Reviews have found small to moderate short-term benefits for pain and function in some groups, although study quality and treatment protocols vary. Differences in needle location, session frequency, practitioner training and comparison groups make the results difficult to reduce to one universal protocol.
A realistic interpretation is that acupuncture may provide symptom relief for selected patients, especially when pain is limiting movement or sleep. Benefits often appear more meaningful when treatment is combined with active rehabilitation. Acupuncture may make it easier to start strengthening exercises, walk further or participate in daily tasks, rather than acting as a stand-alone cure.
The placebo response is relevant, but it does not make symptom improvement meaningless. Clinical encounters, expectation, touch, attention and the physiological effect of needling can all influence pain. A sensible treatment decision considers the size and duration of benefit, cost, convenience and the individual’s preferences.
Evidence from other musculoskeletal conditions is not automatically transferable to knee osteoarthritis. For example, clinical observations about acupuncture for sciatica may help explain how practitioners think about referred or nerve-related pain, but sciatica and knee osteoarthritis involve different structures and should not be treated as the same condition.
Treatment Approaches And Clinical Expectations
An acupuncture programme commonly begins with one or two sessions a week for several weeks, followed by reassessment. The exact schedule depends on symptom severity, access and response. A practitioner may use manual stimulation, electroacupuncture, warming techniques such as moxibustion or adjunctive soft-tissue work, although the evidence for each variation is not identical.
Needles are usually sterile, single-use and very fine. During treatment, a person may feel a brief prick, heaviness, warmth, tingling or a dull ache. Mild bruising, temporary soreness, fatigue or light-headedness can occur. Serious complications are uncommon when treatment is delivered by a properly trained professional using appropriate infection-control procedures.
Acupuncture works best as part of a coordinated plan. Quadriceps and hip strengthening, balance exercises, walking or cycling can improve capacity and confidence. A physiotherapist may adjust exercise intensity around flare-ups, while a dietitian can support gradual weight reduction when appropriate. Even a small reduction in body weight can reduce load through the knee during everyday movement.
Self-care can complement formal treatment. Heat may help stiffness, while a cold pack can be useful after an activity-related flare. Pacing is often better than alternating complete rest with overexertion. Gentle home acupressure and massage may be comfortable for some people; guidance on self-massage techniques concerns headache relief rather than knee arthritis, but it illustrates the importance of using light, controlled pressure and stopping when symptoms worsen.
Medication decisions should be reviewed with a GP or pharmacist. Topical anti-inflammatory gels may suit some people, while oral anti-inflammatory medicines can carry gastrointestinal, kidney and cardiovascular risks. Injections, including corticosteroid injections, may offer temporary relief in selected cases. These choices depend on medical history and should not be replaced by advice from an acupuncturist who is not prescribing medication.
Safety, Regulation And Access In Australia
In Australia, registered Chinese medicine practitioners, including acupuncturists, are regulated by the Chinese Medicine Board of Australia under the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency. Patients can check registration details through the national register. A provider should ask about medical conditions, medicines, bleeding disorders, pregnancy, allergies and previous reactions before needling.
People taking anticoagulants or antiplatelet medicines should disclose this information. Needling over infected skin, open wounds or areas with reduced sensation requires particular caution. Anyone with a pacemaker or other implanted device should discuss electroacupuncture before treatment. Acupuncture should never delay assessment of serious symptoms or substitute for urgent care.
Medicare generally does not provide a broad rebate for acupuncture as an independent service, although some people may access related care through a chronic disease management plan when eligible and clinically appropriate. Private health insurance extras cover differs by policy, provider and annual limit. Fees in Sydney, Brisbane, Perth and Melbourne can vary considerably, and regional or remote patients may need to account for travel and appointment availability.
When judging online health information, it helps to distinguish peer-reviewed evidence, professional guidance and commercial material. Readers may encounter unrelated consumer pages, including trusted gambling reviews, alongside health content in search results. The presence of a polished website does not establish clinical credibility, so patients should look for named authors, references, transparent qualifications and current Australian regulatory information.
A first appointment should include a discussion of goals and a review point. “Less pain when climbing the front steps” is more useful than a vague promise of balance or energy. Keeping a simple record of pain, walking tolerance, sleep and medication use can show whether changes are clinically meaningful.
Choosing A Sustainable Care Plan
The most suitable approach depends on symptom pattern, general health, treatment preferences and available resources. Someone with mild pain may start with education, progressive exercise and occasional acupuncture, while a person with persistent night pain may need a broader medical review. Acupuncture can be considered when the expected benefit justifies the time and expense.
A treatment trial should have defined measures. Pain scores are useful, but function often matters more: walking around the block, using public transport, returning to swimming at the local pool or managing work shifts without a flare. If there is no worthwhile improvement after an agreed period, continuing indefinitely may not be sensible.
The comparison below shows how common options may fit together. They are not mutually exclusive, and the right combination can change as symptoms and goals change.
| Approach | Main purpose | Typical strengths | Important limitations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acupuncture | Reduce pain and support movement | Non-drug option; may help some people engage in exercise | Benefits vary; requires repeated visits |
| Strength and aerobic exercise | Improve capacity, stability and confidence | Strong role in long-term function; low equipment needs | Progress can be uncomfortable and requires consistency |
| Weight management | Reduce mechanical load where relevant | May improve pain, mobility and general health | Results take time; should avoid restrictive or stigmatising approaches |
| Medicines | Provide short-term or flare-related symptom relief | Can support sleep and participation in rehabilitation | Side effects, interactions and limits on long-term use |
| Injections | Reduce pain for selected patients | May provide temporary relief during a severe flare | Benefits are variable and procedures carry risks |
| Knee replacement | Address advanced joint disease | Can substantially improve pain and mobility for suitable patients | Major surgery, rehabilitation and recovery time |
Practical Features Of A Good Plan
- A registered practitioner and clear explanation of the proposed treatment
- A measurable goal, such as walking farther or sleeping more comfortably
- Exercise or rehabilitation that progresses alongside symptom relief
- A review date to assess benefit, side effects and ongoing costs
Questions To Discuss Before Treatment
- How many sessions are recommended before reviewing progress?
- How will the treatment complement physiotherapy or medical care?
- What symptoms should prompt a GP review?
- What rebates, fees and travel requirements apply?
Acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis is best understood as a supportive pain-management option rather than a repair procedure. For some Australians, it may reduce discomfort enough to make exercise and daily activity more achievable. Its value should be judged through safe practice, realistic expectations, measurable function and coordination with evidence-based medical and rehabilitative care.